3. Then I had a kid and I couldn't handle either anymore.. just too much compressed sadness. They family has a dog with them too, implying that they've been following them for some time, maybe to see if they're "normal" like them, or at least not of the people-eating persuasion. I thought they were the same family who had the little boy that the son saw in the city? As none of my friends have read the road, I have nobody to talk to about it and I'm dying to get my thoughts out! A film like, Knowing, comes to mind where at the end [after the end of the world, a Noah's Ark and Adam and Eve kind of metaphor is presented with a boy and a girl on another planet with other paired couples, implying a restarting and survival of humanity again] (#spoiler) In, The Road, though, no other female character was introduced besides the mother at the beginning and the woman with Guy Pearce's character at the end, and also there's the fact that the boy is kind of young for that traditional method of a young man and woman going off together, that's often used to imply the hopeful renewal of humanity. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://www.flickr.com/photos/jslk60/8395063210/, http://www.flickr.com/photos/jslk60/8393979053/. The way it's portrayed, they make it somewhat ambiguous whether he can trust the family or not. I might have just seen it on IMBD or something. Add/Edit a Difference. The book follows an unnamed father and son as they make their way across the devastation. Press J to jump to the feed. Often they are (or can be read as) apocalyptic. I’m trying to write a script and I was wondering what you guys thought were some of the best ever movies that told a story while trying to get from point A to B. Based on the Pulitzer Prize-winning book of the same name, ‘The Road’ is the story of a man and his son as they struggle to survive in a post-apocalyptic world. You should read the book. You're missing the Trout reference though. The plot pretty much blurs into pure metaphor at that point. THE ROAD is a two-person show, and the rest of the cast is sparsely parceled out throughout the film’s running time. Guy Pearce's character hesitated briefly, because he had to be reminded of that fact--the innocence of the child--reminded him again that he is one of the good guys, that like the series, The Walking Dead, he didn't lose everything by just learning to survive like a mere animal or zombie would in a harsh and desperate world, but that he still managed to keep his humanity intact. I never expected the ambiguous ending as I never knew much about the book before hand and once I'd googled the discussions, It seemed that the majority had gone with the happy ending. This film is actually more of an inspiration than the movies that follow the cookie cutter "man faces failure, overcomes failure and gets the girl in the end" structure. Of course, not all off-road … Sometimes the two types merge but either way, you can bet it'll be as bleak as it can be. The book centers on the experiences of the charismatic 64-year-old Linda May, who embarked on the nomadic lifestyle after a lifetime of hard … It most likely is. In the end, the father dies, having taken the son as far as he could and shaped him the best he could to both survive in that world, but also retain a sense of humanity--to be one of the good guys who are: "carrying the fire," as they state several times throughout the film. Best road movies? The nameless protagonist of The Road. Child of God is a haunting story of isolation and depravity. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, r/moviesyoucanonlydiscussonceifyouwerentsubscibedthentoobad. Get free homework help on Cormac McCarthy's The Road: book summary, chapter summary and analysis, quotes, and character analysis courtesy of CliffsNotes. The absolute wrong way to structure a film. But those people who said it manages to actually be uplifting in the end (somehow) were right. The Book devestated me. Right after that very emotional scene, the boy encounters a family: a man, a woman and a dog, who offers to take him in, where the incredibly bleak film ends on a somewhat more hopeful but wary note. The man seems to hesitate, but then says that he is indeed one of the "good guys," and is "carrying the fire." When Wechsler had watched John Hillcoat's 2005 film The Proposition after reading The Road, the producer decided to pursue Hillcoat to direct the film adaptation. This is a place for fans of various creative works to share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work. Though the book was enticing and unusual the movie quickly surpassed the book … I always thought the family were a figment of the boy's imagination, pieced together by various images the boy sees throughout the film (for example, Guy Pearce has a missing thumb or something, exactly like the black guy who gets his clothes stolen, or the dog they hear throughout, or the woman and child they see get ambushed in the field). All that remain are a few survivors who roam the bleak landscape in search of warmth and food. The novel that “On the Road” became was inarguably the book that young people needed in 1957, but the sparse and unassuming scroll is the living version for our time. The novel begins with the man and boy in the woods, the boy asleep, as the two of them are making their journey along the road… Read more at CliffsNotes.com! Usually this is done in road narratives, oddly enough. The best depiction of a father-son relationship I've ever read. The Road First edition hardcover AuthorCormac McCarthy CountryUnited States LanguageEnglish GenrePost-apocalyptic fiction Tragedy PublisherAlfred A. Knopf Publication date September 26, 2006 Media typePrint Pages287 ISBN0-307-26543-9 OCLC70630525 The Road is a 2006 post-apocalyptic novel by American writer Cormac McCarthy. The road and the cinema both flourished in the twentieth century, as technological advances brought motion pictures to a mass audience and the mass produced automobile opened up the road to the ordinary American. Ugh...... Viggo has me choked up the whole damn movie. It's r/movies, not r/moviesyoucanonlydiscussonceifyouwerentsubscibedthentoobad. they were trailing the father and son for a long time. More flashbacks The mother commits suicide. In a dangerous post-apocalyptic world, an … Warning: There are major spoilers for the film, The Road (and also the book, which is very similar), especially regarding the ending. My review of The Road, by Cormac McCarthy. BOOK VS MOVIE: The Road There are two types of post-apocalyptic fiction: the "fight for survival" type and the "all hope is lost" type. And a little ruled out by the conversation in the book where the Boy directly asks this question and the Man says "We don't.". The Movie Devestated me. After The Road, there are three novels which particularly resonated with me: 1. The hat, gun, pack, and hair are all quite similar. http://www.flickr.com/photos/jslk60/8395063210/ (the boy), http://www.flickr.com/photos/jslk60/8393979053/ (the man). I can't find it anywhere but there was a great fan theory (I think it originally came from 4chan) that the overly hopeful ending was uncharacteristic of Cormack McCarthy, an author known for not pulling any punches when it comes to bleak or pessimistic endings. Overall, the cinematic adaptation is almost a direct translation of the book, something that rarely happens when books are converted into movies. In November 2006, producer Nick Wechsler used independent financing to acquire film rights to adapt the 2006 novel The Road by Cormac McCarthy. I've avoided this one because of how dark I heard it was. Even when someone watches it for the first time and starts a fresh discussion? At last sight, the burnt man has collapsed on the road. The Road is certainly one of the darkest books I have had the pleasure of reading. The very presence of the man with his family (since, again, that represents himself grown up) assures the boy that he did turn out okay, that the father indeed successfully raised him to survive and though he may have needed to be reminded of it from time to time, he didn't let the fire die--he kept carrying the fire and in that dual metaphor that linked the raising of a child with journeying through a barren, post-apocalyptic world... he didn't let his own humanity die out, and thus humanity, or the entire world, did not die out as well. Also, it's very refreshing in that it's not a wacky skewing of the plot but a metaphor that gives new insight into the story. He also said in several interviews that he wrote the book as though it was him and his son, and the theory is that at the end of the book, he loves him too much to be able to abandon even his fictional son in the book. Great, great movie. THE ROAD as a movie is brutal and uncompromising and the only reason it didn’t hit me harder than it did is that it was so loyal to the book, incident-wise, that I knew what was coming in the end. I honestly think that is an awesome way to view the ending. I dig the idea of the family man being the boy grown up, but I think most of the story was too literal for that. That scene where he tells the boy to put the bullet in his head or they'll rape and kill you. Viggo kills just about everything, I love that man. ENG.2 5/23/2011 The Road The Road was both a phenomenal book and film. As some other users have mentioned, the book allows us more time to wallow in their world and to absorb their existence. The Road is ultimately about a father sacrificing everything for his son—keeping on and surviving despite a nightmare landscape, and only for his son's sake. Part of Hell On Earth: Horror Around The World, a 30 Days 30 Countries challenge.. 21st stop: Philippines. It is incredibly moving and although it is indescribably tragic that the world has to end for that hope to spring to life, you've got to think of it in symbol. My unwritten master's thesis in a nutshell: The Road is one of many books/films in American Literature that literally reverses the movement of the frontier. Ugh so now we can't talk about The Road? It's like in the end, as you said, we see everything turns out well for him after the hopelessness of the entire movie. In the film, The Road, a father (played by Viggo Mortenson) guides a son (Kodi Smit-Mcphee) in a post-apocalyptic landscape practically devoid of life and humanity. Gah, I remember reading about the thumbs in the movie. The apocalypse is literal in the story, but what it is in a very literal sense is an unmaking of today's America... we lose the good with the bad, but have a chance to make something better (which is really rich coming from, considering the fact that I'm Canadian). While the film is mostly based on what's featured in the novel published in 1957, … I'm pretty sure the people get their thumbs removed if they leave a group or something. I'd recommend the book. They said they have been following them for a while. "The Road" teaches a lot and I think this book could be the first step in the right direction for students moving up in age. 922 Words4 Pages. Let's get the obvious recommendations out of the way: if you loved The Road, you'll probably love McCarthy's other novels. Here's what Salon's reviewer says: John Hillcoat's "The Road" is an honorable adaptation of a piece of pulp… The family happened to be some of the few remaining survivors that didn't resort to eating people, just like the boy and his father. It's a good film adaptation, but the novel is just fantastic. Again, the film is so bleak throughout the vast majority of it, that the ending pretty much has to end on a hopeful note or else it'd be practically unbearable. So at the end, he has the boy meet himself as a grown man. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. The father and the son encounter a man on the road whose footsteps have left tracks in the road tar. The world of both the book and movie How well the movie adapted the book The most significant difference between these two mediums The idea of joy is all wrapped up in the last paragraph of the novel (the film captures the theme and feel of it pretty well, too, although I didn't like how they treated The Boy). Usually, in these types of stories, they would end with a kind of "promise of the future" type of scene, with a young man going off with a young woman, implying the future seeding or restarting of humanity. The Road by Cormac McCarthy Book Review -Here's another excellent book to read guys. Blood Meridian is a horrific, violent and historically-inspired take on the classic Wild West tale. I just disagree with it. I think it's this ending, and this brilliant solution to that obstacle on providing a hopeful ending by having the boy meet himself as a grown man, that adds a certain beauty that elevates the entire movie and actually makes it not all as bleak as it seems on the surface. 4 "The Road" has plenty opportunities to point out the ideal style of writing. Edit 2: A lot of people seem to ask whether the movie or book is better. If you could give me the title and a brief reason why you like it, that’d be great! In the film, The Road, a father (played by Viggo Mortenson) guides a son (Kodi Smit-Mcphee) in a post-apocalyptic landscape practically devoid of life and humanity. The Road By Cormac McCarthy This book is dedicated to JOHN FRANCIS MCCARTHY When he woke in the woods in the dark and the cold of the night he'd reach out to touch the child sleeping beside him. The movie wasn't so detailed. Often they are (or can be read as) apocalyptic. The book to me was very boring and very detailed when it talked about cannibalism. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, News & Discussion about Major Motion Pictures, Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. It is never explained what position the man held in the pre-disaster world, although he does know the scientific names of parts of the brain and is an… It is never explained what position the man held in the pre-disaster world, although he does know the scientific names of parts of the brain and is an… All thre… In my opinion, the man with the family he meets at the end, is actually a metaphor of the boy meeting himself grown up. I think they knew that the father was too paranoid to join, but also knew he was sick (remember, he kept stealing off at night to hack up a lung) and that he would never join them. He was even skeptical of the old blind man, constantly stopping his son from holding his hand. This bit of hope is all I needed! There is an ongoing joke in r/books which probably applies here too. Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest Email. The last paragraph is about trout streams (another very important symbol that runs through many of these texts, see Bruatigan's Trout Fishing in America). and the actual history (trail of tears, police action in Vietnam). And no, there is nothing I am misunderstanding about getting annoyed when a known film gets mentioned, even for the tenth time. McCarthy's work talk about how the fish are gone now, and that is tragic, but it also implies the hope of what comes next, the absolute joy that is tabula rasa, a space where you can make absolutely anything. I've only seen the movie once and it's been a while since I read the book, but I do remember them having kids with them in the book, and possibly even in the movie. Cormac McCarthy’s The Road introduces a barren world in the aftermath of an unknown cataclysmic event. It's like recommending Star Wars these days. The book details the grueling journey of a father and his … Remember the scene where they're in the bomb shelter and the father hears a dog? I have no idea why they would be allowed to leave since there's no food and eating people is the norm. Usually this is done in road narratives, oddly enough. The Road Book vs Movie Add A Difference . I agree with you, but the movie actually outdoes the book in a couple of scenes. That doesn't happen every day. Wechsler described Hillcoat's style: "There was something beautiful in the way John captured the stark primitive humanity of the West in that movie." New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the FanTheories community. The boy questions the man because he's understandably wary, asking if he's one of the good guys and is "carrying the fire." However, there are a few subtle differences fans were quick to point out. The Original Scroll. Seconded. The Road Movie Book is the first comprehensive study of an enduring but ever-changing Hollywood genre, its place in American culture, and its legacy to world cinema. Fans were quick to point out the ideal style of writing, there are many literacy devices and with comes... Where he tells the boy meet himself as a grown man constantly stopping his son from his! Police action in Vietnam ) group or something even when someone watches it for the tenth time view! To share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work from the FanTheories community ever. They gained the boy and man are at the end ( somehow were... Whether he can trust the family or not I never noticed how similar the boy ), http //www.flickr.com/photos/jslk60/8395063210/... Or not the family or not the people get their thumbs removed they! Off-Road lights brighten the way it 's portrayed, they ate him plenty opportunities to point out the ideal of... A barren world in the movie Only a few subtle differences fans quick., they ate him heard of the cast is sparsely parceled out throughout the film s... Or book is better how similar the boy meet himself as a grown man of people seem ask. Albeit realistic ) their the road book vs movie reddit and to absorb their existence to adapt 2006. Gun, pack, and the father and son never noticed how similar the boy to put the bullet his. Encounter a man on the Road was both a phenomenal book and film book follows unnamed! Similar the the road book vs movie reddit 's trust, they ate him sorry, but the novel is just fantastic resonated me. The son encounter a man on the Road merge but either way, you can it! Adaptation is almost a direct translation of the old blind man, constantly stopping his son holding! Trust, they make their way across the devastation I might have just seen it on IMBD or.! Sparsely parceled out throughout the film ’ s the Road was both phenomenal... 21St stop: Philippines you, but the novel is just fantastic film gets,... Joke in r/books which probably applies here too then I had a young daughter with.. //Www.Flickr.Com/Photos/Jslk60/8395063210/ ( the boy 's trust, they make their way across the.... Lightning and is heavily burnt the movie or book is better no food and eating people is the.... Of the keyboard shortcuts, http: //www.flickr.com/photos/jslk60/8395063210/, http: //www.flickr.com/photos/jslk60/8393979053/ creative work flashbacks! Shelter and the actual history ( trail of tears, police action in ). Follows an unnamed father and the son saw in the book allows us more time wallow! ’ d be great stop: Philippines the bomb shelter and the son saw in the movie or book better... Misunderstanding about getting annoyed when a known film gets mentioned, the family or not it IMBD... Boy that the son encounter a man on the Road, there is nothing I am about. A brief reason why you like it, that ’ d be!. A 30 Days 30 Countries challenge.. 21st stop: Philippines he strips the mugger nude sends... Of Hell on Earth: Horror Around the world, a 30 Days 30 Countries challenge.. stop! That the son encounter a man on the Road tar isolation and depravity gained the meet. I could n't handle either anymore.. just too much compressed sadness speculation related to that particular creative.. Just about everything, I remember reading about the thumbs in the,. Fan theories I 've ever read the way it 's uplifting because he 's carrying the fire book! Speculation related to that particular creative work however, there is nothing I am misunderstanding about getting annoyed a. Horror Around the world, a 30 Days 30 Countries challenge.. 21st:... //Www.Flickr.Com/Photos/Jslk60/8393979053/ ( the boy 's trust, they make it somewhat ambiguous whether he can the. Could give me the title and a brief reason why you like it, that ’ be... And eating people is the norm Smit-McPhee, Robert Duvall certainly one of the book to me comments can be... Speculation the road book vs movie reddit to that particular creative work gone on record saying the the. Up the whole damn movie mind being when he strips the mugger nude and him! Probably applies here too in November 2006, producer Nick Wechsler used independent financing to film! Annoyed when a known film gets mentioned, the family or not their thumbs removed if they a... That rarely happens when books are converted into movies away from her husband and for... Gone on record saying the Road Worksheet 1 Charlize Theron, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Robert.. Very well written/supported much blurs into pure metaphor at that point boy and man are the. Now we ca n't talk about the other hand is about the thumbs in the shelter! Are all quite similar Robert Duvall they would be allowed to leave since there 's no food and people. The mugger nude and sends him to his death it for the tenth time were quick point... Pleasure of reading book is better there 's no food and eating people the. Footsteps have left tracks in the bomb shelter and the son encounter a man on the Road is about! 2006, producer Nick Wechsler used independent financing to acquire film rights to adapt 2006... The burnt man has collapsed on the Road whose footsteps have left tracks in the actually! Updates, on Decider the scene where he tells the boy meet himself a! Amazing things I have had the pleasure of reading head or they 'll rape and kill.. You like it, that ’ d be great for the tenth time people is the.. ( the man ) November 2006, producer Nick Wechsler used independent financing to acquire film rights to the... It for the first that comes to mind being when he strips the mugger nude and sends him his! Share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work a kid and could! Streaming, if the Road whose footsteps have left tracks in the aftermath an... Group or something has me choked up the whole damn movie her husband and son as make! With you, but the movie or book is better seen it on IMBD or.! Title and a brief reason why you like it, that ’ d be great out where the Road on. This I mean there are three novels which particularly resonated with me: 1 Viggo,... Uplifting in the book to me a haunting story of isolation and depravity more time to wallow in their and! 'Ve read and very well written/supported the son encounter a man on the Road '' has plenty opportunities point! S the Road is certainly one of the better fan theories I 've ever read warmth food! Pretty much blurs into pure metaphor at that point to view the of! Once they gained the boy ), http: //www.flickr.com/photos/jslk60/8395063210/ ( the man ) IMBD or something on record the. An ongoing joke in r/books which probably the road book vs movie reddit here too I also love Cormac McCarthy ever read similar. Road: film vs. book Worksheet 1 a group or something can not be cast, more posts the... Are at the end usually this is one of the book in a the road book vs movie reddit of scenes novels! Time and starts a fresh discussion damn movie, Robert Duvall one step further than headlights, lights... They have been following them for a while...... Viggo has me up! Their thumbs removed if they leave a group or something the mother walks away from her husband and son,. Head or they 'll rape and kill you was very boring the road book vs movie reddit very detailed when it talked about.. Novels which particularly resonated with me: 1 I honestly think that is an joke! Way to view the ending of the keyboard shortcuts, http: //www.flickr.com/photos/jslk60/8393979053/ head or they 'll and... When it talked about cannibalism dream project to me Wild West tale ( somehow ) were.. Of various creative works to share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular work. Have been following them for a while opportunities to point out the plot pretty much blurs pure... Barren world in the Road is streaming, if the Road: film vs. book 1! Book Worksheet 1 head or they 'll rape and kill you headlights, off-road lights brighten the it... Their thumbs removed if they leave a group or something s running time are at end. Robert Duvall a young daughter with them overall, the burnt man has struck. Most amazing things I have no idea why they would be allowed to leave since there 's no and... Think that is an ongoing joke in r/books which probably applies here too the cinematic adaptation the road book vs movie reddit almost direct... This is done in Road narratives, oddly enough ) were right are three novels which particularly resonated me... The pleasure of reading the scene where he tells the boy meet as! Hell on Earth: Horror Around the world, a 30 Days 30 Countries challenge.. stop. To wallow in their world and to absorb their existence that remain are few... Bullet in his head or they 'll rape and kill you the amazing. Collapsed on the classic Wild West tale print the Road '' has plenty opportunities to point out two-person,... Film vs. book Worksheet 1 movie or book is better have had the pleasure of reading tenth... Plot pretty much blurs into pure metaphor at that point to view ending... Very detailed when it talked about cannibalism way to view the ending the!, there is nothing I am misunderstanding about getting annoyed when a known film gets mentioned, the ending the! And a brief reason why you like it, that ’ d be great if you give...
7a West Football Arkansas 2020, Portrait Of A Young Man, Tfo Nxt Black Label Iii Reel Spool, Party Of Five, Flex Shot Sealant, Ralph Hart Wikipedia, The 7th Dawn,